top of page
  • Alistair Tait

Get ready for the half-baked U.S. Open


How many of us grew up with the words “if you’re not going to do a job properly, then don’t do it at all”? I certainly did, which is why the USGA’s decision to eliminate qualifying for four championships, including the U.S. Open, doesn’t sit right.

The U.S. Open, U.S. Women’s Open, U.S. Amateur and U.S. Women's Amateur will feature all-exempt fields as a result of the chaos caused by the coronavirus. Surely the USGA isn’t that desperate to hold those events this year that it can sweep away tradition with the stroke of a pen?

The governing body still doesn’t know if spectators will be allowed at these events. How can you possibly stage the U.S. Open or U.S. Women’s Open without fans? That would be like holding a fan-less Ryder Cup, and that would never happen, would it? Oh wait, actually…….

Surely it would be better for the USGA just to cancel these four events, as the R&A has wisely done with the Open Championship, rather than stage watered-down tournaments?

In making the announcement, USGA senior managing director of championships John Bodenhamer said:

"As you can imagine, this was an incredibly difficult decision, as qualifying is a cornerstone of USGA championships. We take great pride in the fact that many thousands typically enter to pursue their dream of qualifying for a USGA championship and we deeply regret that they will not have that opportunity this year. But this structure provides the best path forward for us to conduct these championships in 2020."

Obviously not that much pride or the USGA would continue with formats that have stood the test of time.

"We have not taken these decisions lightly and wish we had more options," Bodenhamer added. "But with a continued, keen interest in doing what is best for all involved, although we are extremely disappointed, this is the right decision."

Part of what makes tournaments like the four above great is the fact they’re truly open. Anyone with a decent handicap or a world ranking has a chance to carry off the greatest prizes in American golf.

Take the U.S. Open, which is scheduled for Winged Foot September 17-20. Michael Campbell’s 2005 victory is one of the great stories in U.S. Open history.

The New Zealander (pictured above) had to be talked into qualifying at Sunningdale. He’s glad he did because his subsequent win at Pinehurst proved to be the pinnacle of his career. He beat Tiger Woods by two shots to take the title. Campbell remains one of three Kiwis along with Bob Charles and Lydia Ko to join the major club.

Luca Glover used the qualifying route to win the 2009 U.S Open at Bethpage Black. Ditto for Steve Jones, who defeated Tom Lehman down the stretch at Oakland Hills in 1996. I still remember sitting on the 18th tee in the final round as Lehman hit his tee shot into the left-hand fairway bunker. Lehman, who won the Open Championship the following month, bogeyed the hole to miss out on a playoff.

I understand why the USGA wants to conduct these championships. I know the R&A considered many options for a staging the Open later this year. The R&A could have taken a punt and scheduled a later date in the hope of staging this year’s championship. However, it may have had to comprise the tournament as a result – reduced field, no qualifiers, two-tee start, spectator limits, etc. That was a compromise the governing body was unwilling to make.

I just wish the USGA had done likewise. Not only is there a feel of desperation to the USGA's decision, but the sense it’s staging half-baked tournaments just for the sake of it.

Why do a job if you’re not going to do it properly?

4 comments

Recent Posts

See All

It Pays To Listen To A Good Caddie

There were times reading The Secret Tour Caddie when I wondered if those running men’s professional golf should be replaced by people who perhaps know the professional game better. Those who caddie on

Can Pelley Secure His Golfing Legacy?

You have to wonder when Keith Pelley’s Road to Damascus moment occurred. That’s one thought after reading the outgoing European Tour chief executive’s comments in Dubai this week. “What I would like t

4 Comments


ajt
May 24, 2020

Apology accepted...... Always welcome criticism, as long as its constructive.....

Like

Robopz
Robopz
May 23, 2020

Perhaps I could have better phrased my comments...


The BS part is not about you, it has to do with the praise the R&A is getting from so many quarters for postponing The Open by a year, while the USGA catches flack for trying to find a way to have a US Open. I mean can we be 100% REAL here? R&A's decision was made easy because they have PANDEMIC insurance, while the USGA does not. I would bet my bottom dollar if the R&A didn't have that, they too would have been rigorously examining all options to play the Open this year, with or without fans, on or at a delayed date if possible.... just like the USGA has/…


Like

ajt
May 23, 2020

We'll have to agree to disagree, which I can live with. But please don't accuse me of "BS" and "losing the plot" and then say "regards." Try to be kind, huh? BTW, what's you're real name? It surely can't be "Robopz?" Look forward to your response and revealing your true identity...... All the best.....

Like

Robopz
Robopz
May 20, 2020

Fair opinion that a US Open shouldn't be conducted without qualifying, but IMO your comparison of the USGA doing the wrong thing to the R&A doing the right thing is a totally FALSE narrative. More bordering on BS actually.


R&A had pandemic insurance that allowed them to not even have to consider rescheduling the Open, but notice the R&A has NOT yet cancelled the Women's British Open, Senior British Open or Men's or Women's or Boys or Girls Ams. And you can darn well bet they are considering entry criteria options for those events just as the USGA has. WHY do you suppose that is? No pandemic insurance for those other events is likely one of those reasons? Reportedly …


Like
bottom of page