top of page
  • Alistair Tait

How Would Arnie Have Acted, Phil?

Updated: Oct 16, 2021

Bet the USGA now wish they’d disqualified Phil Mickelson after he hit a moving ball on Shinnecock's 13th green during the third round of the 2018 U.S. Open, especially after the way he criticised the governing bodies for the new rule giving tournament committees the right to limit shaft lengths to 46 inches.

As you can see below, the five-time major winner isn’t too happy about the new decree.

The game’s governing bodies just can’t win. They get criticised if they take too long to respond to an issue – grooves, anchoring, etc – and hammered if they pass a law that just doesn’t sit right with a marquee player.

Thankfully, other name players are supportive of the new Local Rule. Rory McIlroy, chairman of the PGA Tour's player advisory council, said:

"I was in all those meetings when we discussed it for quite a while, and I think the majority of players are on board with it."

Lee Westwood certainly is. He replied to Mickelson on Twitter with:

“What difference does a couple of inches make!?”

Thomas Bjorn tweeted:

“Be interesting to see how many of the long hitters in the game have over 46 inch shafts… I would say, hardly any.”

The 2018 European Ryder Cup captain then added:

“Weird rule that will accomplish nothing!”

I don’t know about you, but it seems Bjorn’s last line is far more diplomatic than Mickelson’s “stupid” take, but then we’re not surprised.

For someone with such popularity, the left hander really lets himself down at times. This is one of those times. So was publicly dissing Tom Watson after the Americans lost the 2014 Ryder Cup match at Gleneagles. No problem with Mickelson feeling aggrieved at Watson’s captaincy, but if ever there was a time when a problem should have been sorted out behind closed doors in the confines of the team room, then that was it. To trash Watson in front of the world’s press in a country where Watson is revered was unforgivable.

Ditto for stopping a moving ball at Shinnecock. He should have been disqualified for that action rather than just docked two shots.

To be fair to Mickelson, he did apologise for his Shinnecock shenanigan. Wonder if he’ll apologise for calling the USGA and R&A stupid?

Maybe the most perplexing aspect to Phil Mickelson is that he’s modelled his career on the late, great Arnold Palmer. Mickelson said as a young professional he saw the way Palmer acted within the game and decided that would be his approach too. It’s why he goes out of his way to sign so many autographs, a policy he’s to be lauded for.

You can bet Palmer would never have stooped to calling the game’s rulers stupid. Too bad Phil didn’t think about that before hitting the Tweet button.

#JustSaying: “Golf requires only a few simple rules and regulations to guide the players in the true nature of its sporting appeal. The spirit of the game is its own referee.” Robert Harris, Sixty Years of Golf

Recent Posts

See All

It Pays To Listen To A Good Caddie

There were times reading The Secret Tour Caddie when I wondered if those running men’s professional golf should be replaced by people who perhaps know the professional game better. Those who caddie on

Can Pelley Secure His Golfing Legacy?

You have to wonder when Keith Pelley’s Road to Damascus moment occurred. That’s one thought after reading the outgoing European Tour chief executive’s comments in Dubai this week. “What I would like t


Madeline Morgan
Madeline Morgan
Oct 16, 2021

The Twitter enter key is a loaded weapon in the fingers of the foolish as tapping it often initiates a flaming, smoking short circuit of the virtual brain/mouth connection.


Oct 16, 2021


Agreed. By all means state your feelings but not in that manner.

Hope you're well.



Oct 15, 2021

You nailed it, Alistair!

In the 1990s I had a chance to see Phil up close at a regular PGA stop. I loved his way of playing daring golf and the fact that he made sure everyone got an autograph and a moment regardless of how his day went. Back then, I pulled for him to win his coveted US Open through all the foibles that he brought on himself.

Fast forward 15 years and the unwinding started at Shinnecock and has continued to this day. Phil has demonstrated that his nothing but a publicity seeking narcissist who cares not about the game or anything else but how he can be benefitted and keep center stage.

I was mostly…

Oct 16, 2021
Replying to


The public trashing of Watson was what flipped it for me. Unforgiveable.



Oct 15, 2021

Love Phil, and everything he's brought to the game... but while he certainly has the right to disagree on this issue, to do so in this way is BS. And not just his broadside directed at the USGA, but his ignorance of his fellow players stance on the issue as well...

My sense is he's already one foot out the door preparing for a hoped for PGL/SGL future anyway... but not sure how this churlish behavior helps either him or them either...

bottom of page