top of page
  • Alistair Tait

Facts matter in battle for golf equality


Woman & Golf editor Emma Ballard hits the nail right on its proverbial head with her first editorial for the publication: facts matter in the battle for equality in golf.


Hideki Matsuyama’s Masters win was historical. His victory was more notable because all and sundry referenced that he’d become the first Japanese man to win a major.


That was significant in this oh so male-dominated game.


As Ballard writes:

“There was a conscious effort not to show bias towards the men’s game and also to recognise the women who had actually accomplished these feats first.
“I am referencing the use of the word “men’s” in the TV coverage, news articles and social media posts over the weekend. It became particularly noticeable after Hideki Matsuyama held the lead after the third round. Was he going to become the first men’s major champion from Japan?
“The build up to the final round and post event saw numerous references to the Japanese women who came before Matsuyama. Both major champions Hisako Higuchi and Hinako Shibuno (pictured) were mentioned as well as the week before belonging to amateur (Tsubasa) Kajitani.”

There was a time when those last facts would probably have been over-looked.


I remember a prominent golf commentator about five years ago saying it was a shame no Scottish player had won a major since Paul Lawrie’s 1999 Open Championship victory at Carnoustie, totally forgetting Catriona Matthew’s fantastic 2009 Ricoh Women’s Open victory at Royal Lytham & St Annes.


Andy Murray had women tennis fans, and quite a few male ones too, cheering to the rooftops when he corrected a journalist in 2017 who said Sam Querrey was the first U.S. player to get to the semi-final of a grand slam since 2009. Murray was quick to say: “Male player.”


Thankfully, Masters competitors didn’t have to correct journalists who might have said Matsuyama was bidding to become the first Japanese player to win a major.


As Ballard writes:

“The fact that Matsuyama's achievement has been celebrated with his female counterparts is almost nothing short of a miracle in the golf world!”

Facts matter. History matters. Perspective matters. For too long the men’s game has totally dominated the golfing world. You could even argue it’s the reason Women & Golf exists. The publishers obviously realised there was a gap in the market, that mainstream publications weren't serving women golfers, and rushed to fill it. The fact that gap existed in the first place is a poor reflection on the game of golf.


Before anyone points out that I’ve worked for mainstream golf publications my entire career, I’d like to think I’ve done my own wee bit to promote equality in this great game. I argued for women to be admitted to our top clubs, especially the Royal & Ancient Golf Club, long before it happened. I’ve also advocated equal prize money in the major championships the R&A, USGA and PGA of America run. I mean, in case they haven’t noticed, it happens in tennis and it is 2021.


Ballard concludes by saying:

“I like to think that this has hopefully signified a tipping point where we become more conscious about the way we reference people and their achievements going forward.
“We all know that we cannot achieve equality overnight, especially in golf, but putting thought behind how we communicate can only have a positive impact on the way the sport is viewed, moving in the right direction away from gender bias and making sure that golf is seen as the inclusive sport that we all know it to be.”

And so say all of us.


#JustSaying: I do not think there is a woman player who is not totally supportive of Andy Murray. He has spoken up for women’s rights, especially in tennis, forever.” Serena Williams


Photograph courtesy of the Ladies European Tour

Recent Posts

See All

It Pays To Listen To A Good Caddie

There were times reading The Secret Tour Caddie when I wondered if those running men’s professional golf should be replaced by people who perhaps know the professional game better. Those who caddie on

Can Pelley Secure His Golfing Legacy?

You have to wonder when Keith Pelley’s Road to Damascus moment occurred. That’s one thought after reading the outgoing European Tour chief executive’s comments in Dubai this week. “What I would like t

3件のコメント


ajt
2021年4月15日

Bill:


I hear you, and Martin Slumbers has given me a similar answer. However, it all goes into the same pot. The R&A governs the game for men and women. Take the prize money of the men's and women's Opens, combine them and split them down the middle. You know as well as I do the top men are not going to skip The Open because it's only a $7.5 million dollar tournament as opposed to a $10.5 million tournament. As for companies that invest in the Open, imagine the positive publicity those companies would receive if their money was going to help the women's game. And imagine the publicity the R&A would get for this positive move. It's a…


いいね!
Robopz
Robopz
2021年4月19日
返信先

Equality in professional sports leagues is obtained when people of all races and gender have the fair right to compete in the commercial marketplace. But what equality does not necessarily produce is equal success in those same market places.


I'm all in for women's golf. But I'm part of such a small audience I can understand their struggles. And a big part of it is that women don't support it. At least in the US, golf viewership is ~ 2/3 men & 1/3 women, for BOTH the PGA tour and the LPGA. But PGA Tour has total viewership 6-8x the LPGA... If the LPGA can't even get women to embrace their league the way men have theirs... Then how do…

いいね!

Bill Elliott
Bill Elliott
2021年4月14日

Agree with almost all of that Al. However there is a problem with equal prizemoney given the disparity in income from all sources between, say, the men's Open and the women's. That's a huge commercial gap. When I wrote for an American magazine I was paid much, much more than for a British one. Same words but they had a bigger reach etc. The point at which ethical stuff hits the money bit is rough territory pal.

いいね!
bottom of page